The Anthropic IPO: Don't Make This Costly Mistake Tomorrow

Matthew Milner

Matthew Milner

Founder

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Do you have plans tomorrow morning?

I sure do. I’ll be glued to my computer screen, waiting for the AI giant Anthropic (ANT) to start trading on the Nasdaq.

Demand for its shares is off the charts. Wall Street’s buzzing. And in an unusual twist, the company is making a juicy portion of its offering available to ordinary investors like you.

But before you rush to buy shares, there’s something you need to know…

Wall Street Can't Get Enough

Before I explain exactly what you need to know, a quick reminder:

Anthropic has set a preliminary IPO price range of $70 to $78 per share. At the midpoint, that implies a valuation of roughly $1.4 trillion.

Even at that eye-watering level, demand has been extraordinary. According to Reuters, by the end of the first week of Anthropic's roadshow, institutional investors had placed orders for approximately six times the number of shares available.

Furthermore, Anthropic is allocating 15% to 20% of its offering to individual investors like you. That's an unusually large allocation. And meanwhile, Vanda Research estimates that, after the IPO, investors like you could purchase $250 million worth of Anthropic shares on its first day of trading. That would be a record.

In other words, Wall Street isn't just inviting institutional investors to the party. It's rolling out the red carpet for everyday investors, too.

But that brings us to a problem.

The Difference Between the IPO Price and the Market Price

Here's something many IPO investors don't understand.

The $70-to-$78 price range is the preliminary price at which Anthropic expects to sell shares in its offering. It's not necessarily the price you'll pay if you buy shares on Thursday morning.

Once trading begins, the stock will be subject to the same forces as any other publicly traded stock — supply, demand, wild excitement, fear, and speculation.

And with a company as highly anticipated as Anthropic, those forces could be extreme.

Imagine the IPO is priced at $78. But when trading opens, investors are still frothing at the mouth to get shares. In that case, the stock could rocket up to $100, $110, or even more.

You might feel lucky to have gotten in. But think about what just happened. You didn't buy Anthropic at the valuation Wall Street negotiated for the IPO. You bought it at a valuation that’s more than 40% higher.

The company hasn't suddenly become 40% more valuable overnight. The only thing that's changed is what investors are willing to pay.

That's dangerous stuff.

Remember the VA Linux Lesson

In last week's article, I told you about VA Linux, a tech company that went public in 1999.

Its shares soared 698% on their first day of trading. Investors who managed to get IPO shares felt like geniuses. But within a year, the stock had lost more than 90% of its value. Ouch.

The company was part of an important technological revolution. But that didn't make its stock a good investment at the price investors were paying.

Sure, Anthropic could be a very different story. Its business, technology, and competitive position are unique. But the underlying lesson hasn't changed:

A great company isn't automatically a great investment.

And the more investors compete to buy shares, the easier it becomes to forget that distinction.

The Smartest Move Might Be to Do Nothing

So what should you do on Thursday?

My advice is simple: Don't feel compelled to buy Anthropic on its first day of trading.

If you receive an allocation of IPO shares at the offering price, that's one thing. (Disclosure: I put in for an allocation, but I don’t know yet how many shares I’ve gotten, or whether I’ll get any at all.) But don't chase the stock if it opens substantially higher.

Instead, let the initial excitement settle down. Watch how shares trade over the next several weeks. Pay attention to the company's financial results, its spending commitments, and its ability to turn revenue growth into real profits.

And remember: You don't have to own a stock on the first day to benefit from its long-term success. Anthropic may ultimately become one of the most important companies of the next decade. I'd certainly never bet against the potential of AI.

But as investors, our job isn't to own every exciting company. It's to buy great companies at prices that leave room for a profit. Sometimes, the best investment decision is to wait.

Happy investing,



Founder
Crowdability.com

Comments

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to updates:

Sign up today and you'll receive our daily insights on early-stage investing, as well as our FREE "Equity Crowdfunding Action Kit" – where you'll learn:

  • The Ins & Outs of Equity Crowdfunding
  • A step-by-step path to get started
  • Tips from dozens of Venture Capitalists

Unsubscribe at any time with a single click.

Tags: Anthropic

Share This:
Comments
comments powered by Disqus